Threads of Memory and Meaning
A Review of If This Were Real
This review is part of our ongoing series of in-house reviews, showcasing how passionate we are about the books we publish.
In If This Were Real, Gerda Stevenson invites readers into a vibrant tapestry of poetry that is as rich and varied as the landscapes of Scotland itself. This new edition of her first full-length collection showcases her remarkable ability to blend the personal with the political, weaving together themes of childhood, memory and the broader human experience in a way that is both poignant and powerful.
Stevenson's poetry dances gracefully between the nostalgic echoes of skipping rhymes and the more profound laments of loss and injustice. The collection captures the essence
of fleeting moments, like the delicate flutter of butterflies or the crispness of snowberries, while also bravely confronting heavier subjects such as the conflicts in Bosnia and Iraq. This duality creates a compelling narrative that resonates deeply with readers, inviting them to reflect on their own shared humanity.
Critics have hailed the collection as a significant contribution to contemporary Scottish poetry. Ron Butlin describes it as "the best of the new," emphasising its must-read status. Kevin MacNeil draws parallels to Iain Crichton Smith’s A Life, highlighting Stevenson’s unique style while recognising her ability to evoke empathy and insight through her verses. The poems range from humorous to heart-wrenching, with a musicality that enhances their impact.
What stands out in this collection is Stevenson's compassionate voice, which is both honest and defiant. She captures the inherent fragility of life, exploring the fallibilities of human nature with an edgy panache that is refreshing and thought-provoking. Each poem feels like a complete story, deftly encapsulating complex emotions in a few carefully chosen words.
In a world that often feels overwhelming, If This Were Real serves as a comforting yet challenging companion. It provides moments of joy and clarity, grounding readers while simultaneously elevating their spirits. As Fiona Erskine notes, the collection's “musical Scottish cadence” feels familiar, yet it is imbued with an undercurrent of power that surprises and moves.
Gerda Stevenson’s If This Were Real is a journey through the landscapes of memory, identity, and the human condition. This book is a treasure for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the world around them, and it is sure to leave a lasting impression on all who read it.
