Reassessing Devolution
A Review of Unfinished Business
This review is part of our ongoing series of in-house reviews, showcasing how passionate we are about the books we publish.
In Unfinished Business, former First Minister Henry McLeish and Professor James Mitchell offer a timely and insightful examination of Scotland's political journey since the establishment of the Scottish Parliament in 1999. Drawing from their extensive experience and expertise, the authors provide a comprehensive analysis of devolution's achievements, challenges and the pressing need for reform.
The book begins by revisiting the foundational principles set out by the Consultative Steering Group (CSG) in 1998: sharing power, accountability, accessibility and equality. McLeish and Mitchell assess how these ideals have been realised over the past quarter-century and where they have fallen short. They argue that while devolution has brought about significant changes, it has also led to a political stalemate, with the debate over independence overshadowing other critical issues facing Scotland.
The authors delve into various aspects of Scottish governance, highlighting both successes and areas needing attention. They discuss the complexities of a multi-party system, the challenges of coalition politics, and the evolving relationship between Scotland and the rest of the UK. Through this analysis, McLeish and Mitchell advocate for a more collaborative and forward-thinking approach to governance, one that moves beyond the binary debate of independence versus union.
Unfinished Business is an essential read for anyone interested in the future of Scottish politics. It offers a balanced and informed perspective on the evolution of devolution, recognising both its achievements and shortcomings. McLeish and Mitchell's call for a renewed focus on the core principles of devolution serves as a timely reminder of the need for continuous reflection and reform in the pursuit of a more equitable and effective democracy.
For those looking to explore Scotland's political landscape, Unfinished Business provides a thoughtful and engaging analysis that is both accessible and thought-provoking.
