A Case of Desecration in the West
Book Review
This review is part of our ongoing series of in-house reviews, showcasing how passionate we are about the books we publish.
Douglas Watt’s historical mystery A Case of Desecration in the West plunges readers into the shadowy heart of Scotland in 1691, where hooded figures haunt the woods and graves are desecrated under the shroud of night. Against this macabre backdrop, a drowned body in the River Clyde sparks a compelling investigation led by the shrewd John MacKenzie and his ever-loyal assistant, Davie Scougall.
The story kicks off with the disturbing discovery of Bethia Porterfield's body, and the local authorities quickly deem her death a suicide. However, the formidable Duchess of Hamilton is not satisfied with this convenient conclusion. With her unwavering determination to seek the truth, she enlists the help of MacKenzie and Scougall to dig deeper into the mystery surrounding Bethia’s demise.
Watt masterfully recreates the atmosphere of late 17th-century Scotland, painting a vivid picture of a society steeped in superstition, political intrigue and religious conflict. The novel’s opening scenes, depicting eerie rituals and nocturnal grave-robbing, set a chilling tone that permeates the entire narrative. As MacKenzie and Scougall delve into their investigation, they encounter a web of secrets and lies that forces them to question the nature of truth and justice in a world where appearances are often deceiving.
The characters in A Case of Desecration in the West are richly drawn and complex. John MacKenzie, the astute and tenacious detective, embodies the relentless pursuit of truth, even when faced with considerable personal risk. His assistant, Davie Scougall, provides both loyal support and a contrasting perspective that enriches their partnership. The Duchess of Hamilton, with her fierce intelligence and unyielding resolve, emerges as a powerful and compelling figure, driving the narrative forward.
Watt's prose is both evocative and precise, capturing the essence of the period while maintaining a brisk and engaging pace. The dialogue is sharp and often laced with wit, providing moments of levity amidst the darker themes. The plot is intricately woven, with each twist and turn revealing new layers of the mystery, keeping readers on the edge of their seats until the very end.
A Case of Desecration in the West is a compelling addition to Douglas Watt’s John Mackenzie series, blending historical accuracy with a gripping mystery that will captivate readers from start to finish. It's a tale of dark secrets, dogged determination and the relentless quest for justice in a world where nothing is as it seems. For fans of historical mysteries and anyone who enjoys a well-crafted, atmospheric thriller, this book is an absolute must-read.
